Find hotels in Fishers Island, NY from ฿2,579

"When I booked, it said some free continental breakfast with options of other items could be purchased in the restaurant. The only free thing was coffee. No free food. We did eat in the restaurant and the cook said she wasnt making poached eggs that day so I ordered over easy, which were a bit overdone. Our waitress was very nice! Another patron argued the same thing about the free breakfast. I always book hotels with free continental breakfast, so was a bit disappointed. I did use the jet tub and even though it felt nice, it left a brown ring of bubbles. But other than that, the room was very clean. Everyone was very nice."

"Pool was great and staff was geeat"

"Parking was nearby ands check in was easy and quick. Our room was spacious, clean and updated. The breakfast is always good, and the coffee is so tasty too! Always our go-to place when we are in the area "

"The hotel is always near and clean for our stays. A few things were a bit off the usual experiences. A desk employee on the 12th was a bit unprofessional when we inquired if our room was ready. The person who checked us in when our room was ready was great. The pool was cold on the second day due to new water added. Tried to get breakfast to go this morning from the Iron no one ever came to take our order despite a gentleman telling us someone would be over. Overall our experiences have been very good here but not quite hitting the mark on this trip. "

"Yes,, plenty of shops and food choices.buy need more $5 black tables "

"forgot credit card at front desk at check in. was never notified while there. Drove an hour back to get card and was told they didnt have access to it. Called next day, card is now missing. Left cell and info (which they already had) and asked for manager to call me back asap. Never got a call. will never stay there again."

"Great location to all Mystic activities and great room for a family of 5. "

"Our family of four stayed for 3 nights in a two bedroom suite with ocean views. We booked it last minute for spring break. Overall, we had an amazing time and enjoyed our stay despite the cold temps. The room was clean. I saw no obvious signs of aging of furniture, fittings and walls - a huge plus given the volume of people it must see. We chose to have breakfasts, lunches and one evening's dinner outside of the resort. The only area I thought they could have done better is the consistency of the communication and countenance of the staff. Front desk was excellent - smiles, eye contact and clear communication. Cleaner was happy, smiles and positive. Gigi's maitre d' was polite and prompt but we're out of New York, it'll be nice to have some warmth through a smile and eye contact. Similarly, while one evening's waiter, Felix, was phenomenal in his ability to connect professionally with us, the next night's waiter did not. I can understand that they must see a variety of individuals every day and it can wear on their emotions (perhaps some individuals are rude to them?) but they are in customer facing roles and each new table is an opportunity to bring some warmth and enjoyment to a new customer's experience. We'd go again and adjust our expectations of Gigi's dining experience. "

"The staff were very friendly, rooms were nice"