Find hotels in Fire Island Pines, NY from ฿3,741

"It was very clean. The food was ok. Pool was great. The bed was ok."

"Nice room"

"The Hotel itself looks like it’s under construction. Each floors ice machine was out of service but the staff was so friendly that it made up for the hotel’s conditions. I would stay again "

"My stay was and always exceptional and excellent. The restaurant food is delicious, the environment is very quiet and safe. The property is well kept abd very clean. The rooms are very clean spacious and beds are comfortable. The staffs overall are very friendly and professional. I'm in love going to Jake's 58 I enjoyed all my stays there and recommend my friends,families and coworkers. I just celebrate my stepmom birthday there last month and she had an amazing time."

"Overall it is good for the price. They charge parking $15/night for parking in an open parking lot in a mall area right next to 2 restaurants, I cannot understand the logic."

"recommend this location for the clean spaces and friendly reception"

"Buffett breakfast was blah. Never recieved extra towels and bedding we requested. Pool was cold hot tub was warm. "

"The staff was great, the property is very run down, as you walk in the wall paper is falling off the wall, ceiling is water stained, carpets are stretched out and lose, gyn equipment being stored in restaurant, hallways are extremely dirty, window view trash in courtyard, fence broken apart and just laying there. Miniature pillows on the bed. Hole in wall above the bathroom mirror, felt like i was staying in the ghetto. "

"Hotel messy, mattresses all over the lobby. Rooms were fairly clean looks like they have tried to update them. Tv wouldn’t work , no one could fix it. Breakfast was very limited options. "