The Best Hotels Closest to Bay Street Theatre in Sag Harbor - 2026 Updated Prices

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Our top choices for Bay Street Theatre hotels

A waterfront property with a large house, multiple boats docked, and lush greenery.

1. Sag Harbor Inn

0.6 km from Bay Street Theatre

Annie

฿8,407 total

includes taxes & fees

8 Nov - 9 Nov

A pool area with umbrellas, potted plants, and a pathway leading to a building.

2. Faraway Sag Harbor

0.5 km from Bay Street Theatre

Thomas

฿13,682 total

includes taxes & fees

6 Dec - 7 Dec

A modern bathroom with a large mirror, wooden vanity, and a sink. There is a chair and a small table in the adjacent living area, with a sofa and a view of the outdoors.

3. The Bentley Hotel Southampton

18.7 km from Bay Street Theatre

Armando

฿5,515 total

includes taxes & fees

19 Nov - 20 Nov

4. East Hampton House Resort

11.3 km from Bay Street Theatre

Tina

฿6,463 total

includes taxes & fees

9 Nov - 10 Nov

A two-story house with a balcony, outdoor seating area, and a variety of plants.

5. Zey Hotel

12.6 km from Bay Street Theatre

Renee

฿6,194 total

includes taxes & fees

18 Nov - 19 Nov

The entrance to The Harbor Front Inn with a double door and the address number 209.

6. The Harbor Front Inn

12.4 km from Bay Street Theatre

Laura

฿6,643 total

includes taxes & fees

7 Dec - 8 Dec

A wooden pathway leading to beach chairs and umbrellas, surrounded by lush greenery and a view of the sea.

7. Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

12.3 km from Bay Street Theatre

Becky

฿9,559 total

includes taxes & fees

7 Dec - 8 Dec

Two bicycles with wicker baskets labeled "Sophie & Co." parked in front of a building with a dark door and white columns.

8. The Sagaponack

7 km from Bay Street Theatre

Jane

฿9,204 total

includes taxes & fees

8 Nov - 9 Nov

A modern building with a wooden exterior, a balcony, and a pathway lined with potted plants and stepping stones.

9. Journey East Hampton

12 km from Bay Street Theatre

Erika

฿9,311 total

includes taxes & fees

22 Nov - 23 Nov

A modern house with a deck, outdoor seating, and a fire pit.

10. North Fork Resort

13.4 km from Bay Street Theatre

Altynai

฿12,285 total

includes taxes & fees

16 Nov - 17 Nov

An outdoor dining area with a table and chairs, surrounded by tall trees and string lights.

11. A Room At The Beach

7 km from Bay Street Theatre

Annabel

฿11,367 total

includes taxes & fees

8 Nov - 9 Nov

A modern outdoor seating area with two wicker chairs and a small table, overlooking a body of water and a wooden deck.

12. The Shoals Suites and Slips

12.3 km from Bay Street Theatre

Masayo

฿7,929 total

includes taxes & fees

16 Nov - 17 Nov

A beach with waves gently lapping onto the shore.

13. The Roundtree, Amagansett

13.3 km from Bay Street Theatre

Dwight

฿23,860 total

includes taxes & fees

3 Dec - 4 Dec

A modern building with a pool, featuring a dining area with tables and chairs, and a glass entrance.

14. Topping Rose House

7.2 km from Bay Street Theatre

Adam

฿24,032 total

includes taxes & fees

7 Nov - 8 Nov

A glass-top table with a vase of flowers, surrounded by white-covered chairs, in a bright indoor setting with plants and a fireplace in the background.

15. Hamlet Inn

18.4 km from Bay Street Theatre

Eric

฿4,633 total

includes taxes & fees

11 Nov - 12 Nov

16. Southampton Inn

15.6 km from Bay Street Theatre

Kevin

฿8,192 total

includes taxes & fees

8 Nov - 9 Nov

A beach with a lifeguard tower, sandy dunes, and the ocean.

17. The Huntting Inn

10.2 km from Bay Street Theatre

Josie

฿13,219 total

includes taxes & fees

29 Nov - 30 Nov

A large, multi-story building with a swimming pool, outdoor seating, and a well-maintained garden.

18. East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast

12.6 km from Bay Street Theatre

IVAN

฿17,293 total

includes taxes & fees

7 Dec - 8 Dec

A house with a sloped roof, large windows, and a pathway leading to the entrance.

19. Mill House Inn

10.2 km from Bay Street Theatre

Rhett

฿15,719 total

includes taxes & fees

18 Nov - 19 Nov

A covered patio area with outdoor seating, a potted plant, and a well-maintained lawn.

20. Southampton Long Island Hotel

15.4 km from Bay Street Theatre

William

฿5,946 total

includes taxes & fees

1 Dec - 2 Dec

View all properties

Compare popular hotels close to Bay Street Theatre

Property	Property class	Guest rating
Sag Harbor Inn	3.5 star property	9.4 Exceptional 686 reviews	View
Faraway Sag Harbor	4.0 star property	9.0 Wonderful 320 reviews	View
The Bentley Hotel Southampton	2.0 star property	9.6 Exceptional 615 reviews	View
East Hampton House Resort	3.0 star property	9.0 Wonderful 351 reviews	View
Zey Hotel	3.5 star property	9.2 Wonderful 444 reviews	View

Other attractions near Bay Street Theatre

A harbor with several sailing ships and a mountainous landscape in the background.

Sag Harbor Marine Park

8.8/10 (20 reviews)

Sag Harbor Marine Park is just one of the places to see in Sag Harbor, so why not enjoy the other things to explore during your travels? While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches.

See properties

Top Bay Street Theatre Hotel Reviews

An outdoor dining area with trees and tables under string lights.

The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

East Hampton

10/10 Excellent

Liina

Faraway Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor

10/10 Excellent

Thoroughly enjoyed my stay at Baron's Cove. I stayed late February so the pool was closed, but this was expected. It's a motel style hotel where your door opens to the outside, but given the location of the hotel i felt perfectly safe. The Staff were fantastic, and always helpful. The breakfast was first class too. Sag Harbor is such an iconic place within the Hamptons and this hotel is just as iconic in my eyes. The decor, is photo-worthy. I certainly hope to come back again soon!

Nathan

The Shoals Suites and Slips

Southold

10/10 Excellent

Paul

A Room At The Beach

Bridgehampton

8/10 Good

Travelled with a friend at the end of Sept . Quiet time for the hotel which is lovely. Good points : stunning garden! Amount of work that it takes to maintain such beautiful plants is impressive . Stylish outdoor furnitures . Bed and pillows were very comfortable . Had a great night sleep . Free water and rose which was a nice touch Improvement points : Eventhough it’s off season , one of the more pricey hotels I’ve ever stayed in prob because of the location .With that price point , there...

Vee Han

The Bentley Hotel Southampton

Southampton

10/10 Excellent

James

A tented area with a pool view, wooden lounge chairs, and a table with a drink and food.

Canoe Place Inn and Cottages

Hampton Bays

10/10 Excellent

Ann marie

Journey East Hampton

East Hampton North

10/10 Excellent

Natalie

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the area like around Bay Street Theatre?

Bay Street Theatre is located in an area of Sag Harbor known for its beautiful beaches. If you're looking for a convenient place to stay, take a look at the 96 hotels and other accommodation options you'll find within a mile.

What's the best hotel to stay near Bay Street Theatre?

Faraway Sag Harbor is one of the top choices for your stay based on our traveller data, and this hotel offers a restaurant and free valet parking. It's located just a short 0.3 mi (0.5 km) from Bay Street Theatre. Another good choice is Sag Harbor Inn, located just 0.4 mi (0.6 km) away.

How many hotels should I expect to find near Bay Street Theatre?

Expedia has 96 hotels and other accommodation options within a mile from Bay Street Theatre.

If I need to cancel the hotel reservation for my stay near Bay Street Theatre, will I receive a refund?

Yes! Most hotel bookings are refundable provided that you cancel prior to the accommodation's cancellation deadline, which in most cases is within 24 or 48 hours of your arrival date. If you have a non-refundable reservation, it might still be possible to cancel it and be given a refund within a 24-hour period of your booking. Add dates, click "Search", then filter by "fully refundable" to get the top deals on offer near Bay Street Theatre.

What can I see and do near Bay Street Theatre?

Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, South Fork Natural History Museum and Nature Center and Havens House feature captivating exhibits. Sights like St. David AME Zion Church and Eastville Heritage House highlight some of the local culture. Get outside and spend some time strolling around Mashomack Preserve, Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge and Mashashimuet Park.

Search Hotels Near Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Filter by

Property class

Guest rating

Our top choices for Bay Street Theatre hotels

1. Sag Harbor Inn

2. Faraway Sag Harbor

3. The Bentley Hotel Southampton

4. East Hampton House Resort

5. Zey Hotel

6. The Harbor Front Inn

7. Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

8. The Sagaponack

9. Journey East Hampton

10. North Fork Resort

11. A Room At The Beach

12. The Shoals Suites and Slips

13. The Roundtree, Amagansett

14. Topping Rose House

15. Hamlet Inn

16. Southampton Inn

17. The Huntting Inn

18. East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast

19. Mill House Inn

20. Southampton Long Island Hotel

Compare popular hotels close to Bay Street Theatre

Other attractions near Bay Street Theatre

Sag Harbor Marine Park

Top Bay Street Theatre Hotel Reviews

The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

10/10 Excellent

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the area like around Bay Street Theatre?

What's the best hotel to stay near Bay Street Theatre?

How many hotels should I expect to find near Bay Street Theatre?

If I need to cancel the hotel reservation for my stay near Bay Street Theatre, will I receive a refund?

What can I see and do near Bay Street Theatre?