Marina Hotels

"Great stay. Need drinking water access maybe by ice and coffee"

"Within walking distance of the night life. Right off the harbor with affordable prices for boat rides. Right along the boardwalk."

"Location was great!!!"

"The bed was simply comfortable. Good sleeping bed. The overall Hotel does need some updating. Everything is dated but clean. We come every Summer for our getaway to the coast. Conveniently located to everything, especially restaurants."

"Beautiful resort and amenities. Our family had a great time"

"Location great, breakfast super, roof top pool amazing, some of the roof top furniture could do with fixing . Rooms were lovely and clean. Staff friendly and helpful."

"Ice machine was always empty, at $270 and completely booked…service it or buy another one. One other thing is early check in, $25 is a ridiculous offer. Reason why is at 4pm you have one staff member and clients out the door waiting to check in for the next two hours. Other than that it was a great ..."

"Although the Bay Club is older, you would never know it. The facilities are so very well kept. The rooms are extremely spacious and the location is beautiful. The food at the restaurant was phenomenal as well. Highly recommend staying here if ever on Shelter Island."

"Great view, quite,staff was excellent,clean room,great restaurant around bay. This is our 3rd stay here. Just a peaceful place to stay"

"A great 5 night holiday. Location around the marina was perfect with great dining options. The hotel was perfect , we had an interconnecting room and pool area was social."